New favorite!!! "New favorite mascara! I love this stuff. The brush is perfect. It adds length and goes on smooth. No smudges throughout the day, no melting off when I sweat, and it washes off with my normal oil makeup remover. Waterproof mascara does take a little more work to remove at the end of the day, but totally worth it!" — Jenny S. (5/5)
Splashes Waterproof Mascara "I've used it for years, & works great but starts to run out pretty quickly, which is a newer development over the past year. I usually need to re-up every 2-3 months now, whereas before it lasted for like 4-5 months, so not sure if they changed the formula or what. Still great though, just know you will have to spend $ more often." — Sarah M. (4/5)
Tried and true "This is my go-to mascara for years. The original Lights, Camera, Lashes is great, but I absolutely love that the waterproof version stays on without fail until I choose to take it off. It seems to work best when fresh, so I enjoy getting travel size tubes when they're available. I haven't tried the maneater waterproof mascara yet to compare with this formula." — Erin (5/5)
Lashes for Days! "I loved how light it sits on my lashes. It also actually helped my lashes show up on my face with a full face of makeup" — Alyse (5/5)
ANNOYING CONTAINER "This was the first waterproof version I purchased. I love the regular version. But my first thought when I opened the box was, "Am I supposed to remove this leather cover?" I googled it and discovered that this awkward cover keeps the user from closing the wand tightly enough after using to keep the mascara from drying out prematurely. Not a good marketing plan. I don't know that I will buy again." — KATHLEEN F. (3/5)
Brush could be better "I like the formula of the mascara, but the brush doesn't do a very good job separating my lashes. The brush seems to always causes me to get mascara on the skin next to my eye and on my eye lid, which means I have to clean up around my eyes after I'm finished applying. I wish the brush head was a little smaller and the bristles more fine to separate lashes and reduce the globbiness." — Heather G. (4/5)
"Seems very dry, almost as if its an old tube. Bristles are very short, which cause you to get mascara on the eyelids. Water proof works as described. Overall disappointing for the $25 pricetag." — C (3/5)
